The Best Key Lime Pie Martini Recipe From Key West Florida

Happy New Years Eve! I love the holidays, and I’m super excited this year because we came home for Christmas! Whenever I land in the Keys, my first stop, yes my first stop, is the liquor store to pick up some Keke Key Lime Liquor so I can make a key lime pie martini recipe!

Key Lime Pie Martini Recipe From Key West Florida

Key Lime Pie Martini Recipe                            From Key West Florida

Man oh man, I love this stuff! It taste like citrus, but is sweet, creamy, and has a kick! These martinis go down easy like you’re having key lime pie. So watch out! If you drink too many, you could find yourself sleeping on the beach! I rim the glass in graham crackers and top it off with vodka-infused lime whipped cream. Oh yeah!

Key Lime Pie Martini Recipe From Key West Florida


It’s always better to share one with your honey – my hubby and I usually pour them and sit on the beach watching the sunset!

Key Lime Martini Recipe (for 2)


  • Key Lime Pie Martini Recipe From Key West Florida
    Key Lime Pie Martini Recipe
    Recipe Image
    Save RecipeSave Recipe


    • Keke Key Lime Liquor - 2 shots/3 oz
    • Vanilla vodka - 2 shots/3 oz
    • Pineapple juice - 1 shot/1.5 oz (Dole Pineapple Juice)
    • Heavy cream or half & half - 1 shot/1.5 oz (I use Trader Joe's Whipping Cream)
    • 1 key lime cut into wedges
    • Whipped cream
    • Ice
    • Graham Cracker crumbs
    • 2 martini glasses


    1. First, get a cocktail shaker and fill it with ice!
    2. Next, take your graham cracker crumbs and pour some onto a small plate.
    3. Take a lime wedge and run it around the rim of your glass. Then, dip your glass into the crumbs to rim your glass! Oh my, I can already taste it!
    4. Next, fill your shaker with ice, pour your liquor, juice, and cream. Now shake, shake, shake that shaker to mix the ingredients! Don't forget to put the lid on before shaking or you will have key lime martini all over your kitchen!

There you have it! A delicious, Key Lime pie martini recipe! Enjoy! Have you made this did you love it? Please leave us a comment and let me know.  If you are visiting the area, check out our article on the Dry Tortugas National Park.  near Key West.  Are you Visiting Key West? Try out the Food and Drink walking tour of the Historic seaport and town! Compare Tour Prices Here!

– Stacey

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe:
CommentLuv badge
  1. Pingback: 20 Ideas for Key Lime Pie Martini - Best Recipes Ever

  2. Hi!! Would love to make this, where can I purchase the liquor? I tried amazon but no luck... any suggestions? Thanks Brooke
  3. My lesbian :-) key lime martiny recipe THANK YOU but where I can find UR best burritos and gues what . . . your special cheesecake :-) XXX
    • Actually the My Key lime Martini Recipe is here silly And miss you thank you for reading! --
  4. I almost couldn't finish reading this article. :P This sounds like literally the best thing ever. I am obsessed with key lime pie. This is definitely getting bookmarked and I will try it when I get back to the US
  5. My daughter worked at a bar where they sold this as a Key Lime Pie Martini. I swear that's what it tastes like, a key lime pie. Whatever it's called, it's absolutely DELICIOUS. The only problem is that it's too easy to keep drinking them because they taste so darn good..